Malignant Melanocytic Lesions
Authors: Dr Haya Alani, Dr Charlotte Michelmore, Dr Kalina Bridegwater
Chief Editor: Dr Daniel Keith
This section will cover:
-
Dysplastic Naevus
-
Melanoma-in-situ
-
Malignant Melanoma
Introduction
Melanoma skin cancer is the fifth most common cancer in the UK, but fortunately has one of the lowest and a decreasing mortality rate due to the game-changing treatment of immunotherapy over the last decade. Melanoma is a type of skin cancer that arises from melanocytes, the pigment-producing cells in the skin, and less commonly from mucosal surfaces, under the nails and in the meninges. It is caused by UV exposure. It is the most aggressive form of skin cancer as it commonly metastasises to other body sites.
Melanomas may arise de novo in normal skin, or from established benign melanocytic naevi (moles), which undergo abnormal changes. There is a spectrum from benign melanocytic naevi to dysplastic naevi, which can progress to melanoma in situ or invasive malignant melanoma. Benign melanocytic lesions is covered on a separate page on this website. Dysplastic naevi, melanoma in situ and malignant melanoma are explained below.
Dysplastic Naevus
An atypical naevus is a mole with abnormal features on examination including:
- irregular shape and borders
- varying shades of colour
- may have a mixture of flat and raised components
- size often > 5mm diameter
We call these moles ‘dysplastic’ naevi when they have a defined criteria of abnormal features on histological assessment once they have been surgically removed. They are not cancerous themselves, but they can be challenging to distinguish from melanomas. They also have a higher chance of developing into melanomas in the future and are therefore best removed.
Melanoma-In-Situ
Melanoma in-situ is an early form of primary melanoma, where malignant cells are confined to the epidermis only, with no opportunity to spread beyond this top layer of skin to anywhere else in the body. Technically this is a pre-cancerous change and is also known as Stage 0 melanoma as per the AJCC classification listed below. This has a very good prognosis and is usually cured by surgical removal with a margin of normal skin around the lesion. However, if not treated appropriately, melanoma in situ can develop into malignant melanoma.
Malignant Melanoma
Malignant melanomas arise when melanoma cells spread beyond the epidermis, to deeper layers of the skin such as the dermis or subcutaneous fat, or beyond this to other parts of the body such as lymph nodes and distant organs.
The Breslow thickness, which measures how far a melanoma has grown into the skin, is very important. The thicker the melanoma, the worse the prognosis. The American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging classification takes tumour thickness into account, alongside other factors, which are briefly summarised below:
Stage 0 / Tis – melanoma in situ, contained to epidermis
Stage 1A – <0.8 mm thick + not ulcerated
Stage 1B – 0-1mm thick + ulcerated OR 0.8 - 2 mm thick + not ulcerated
Stage 2A – 1-2 mm thick + ulcerated OR 2-4 mm thick + not ulcerated
Stage 2B – 2 - 4 mm thick + ulcerated OR >4 mm + not ulcerated
Stage 2C – > 4 mm + ulcerated
Stage 3 – ‘Locally advanced’ melanoma with spread between primary tumour and regional lymph nodes
Stage 4 – ‘Advanced’ melanoma with metastatic spread beyond regional lymph nodes
The patient will often have recognised a distinctive new lesion or an established lesion that has changed. The useful ‘ABCDE’ acronym is widely known by the public and clinicians as a way of remembering the clinical features of melanoma.
-
Asymmetry
-
Border irregularity
-
Colour variability / Change
-
Diameter - increase in size, often > 6mm
-
Evolving
Dermoscopic Features
Appreciating the dermoscopic features of melanomas is crucial for distinguishing them from benign skin lesions and other skin cancers. Suspicious lesions require urgent surgical removal for accurate diagnosis on histology. Dermoscopic assessment of skin lesions can help to diagnose melanomas at an earlier stage, which is important as these will have a better prognosis. It can be difficult to differentiate melanoma from benign skin lesions such as atypical/ dysplastic naevi, seborrheoic keratosis and solar lentigines by simple clinical examination. The following dermoscopic features are indicative of melanomas and can aid their diagnosis:
-
Atypical/irregular pigment network: melanomas often exhibit variations in colour, ranging from shades of brown, black, red, blue, grey or white, with irregular holes and varying thickness of lines within the network. The pigment network can display a sharply cut-off border. A negative network can also be seen where the pigment network is hypo/depigmented.
-
Irregular dots/globules: black or brown, round or oval, variously sized pigmented structures, irregularly distributed within the lesion. Dark dots and globules are commonly seen at the peripheries.
-
Streaks: radial lines with or without a bulbous projection at their peripheral ending, irregularly distributed at the periphery of the lesion. They may arise from network structures but more often do not. They range from tan colour to black. These can also be known as Pseudopods.
-
Regression structures: they correspond to a clinically flat part of the lesion and can be a white-scar like depigmented area or a blue-grey pepper-like granule.
-
Asymmetric structures: unlike most benign moles which are usually symmetrical in shape, melanomas often exhibit asymmetry. This asymmetry can be observed in the irregular distribution of pigment, vessels, and overall structure within the lesion.
-
"Ugly duckling" sign: this refers to a lesion that looks noticeably different from the surrounding moles on the same individual. By comparing the dermoscopic features of multiple lesions on the same patient, dermatologists can identify any outlier that stands out as an "ugly duckling" and warrants further evaluation for potential malignancy.
-
Atypical vessels: irregular, disorganized, or polymorphic vessels (more than one type) that differ from the normal vascular pattern observed in benign lesions. These atypical vessels can appear as dotted, linear, or branched structures within the lesion, indicative of the neoangiogenesis process associated with melanoma growth.
-
Blue-white veils: a hazy or milky bluish-white discoloration seen on the surface of the lesion. This feature is thought to be due to dermal fibrosis or melanin deposition within the lesion, reflecting the invasive nature of melanoma cells into the deeper layers of the skin.
Dysplastic naevi and melanoma in situ will have less severe versions of the dermoscopic features listed above, with increasing irregularity and disorganisation as you progress towards the melanoma end of the spectrum. It can be difficult to distinguish between these entities clinically and histological diagnosis is therefore essential. Below are examples of annotated dermoscopic images for each type of lesion.
Dysplastic Naevus - examples

Figure 1a.
Lesion with a regular shape suggestive of a benign melanocytic naevus, but the darker area of pigmentation at the inferior pole rouses suspicion of an atypical lesion. Proven to be a dysplastic naevus on histology.

Figure 1b - Dermoscopic image of the same lesion shows the irregular features more clearly.

Figure 2a.
This is a tricky one. Overall it looks quite symmetrical and it has a central darkly pigmented structureless blotch that you can find in benign moles. However, on closer review there are concerning features as annotated.
This is another dysplastic naevus proven by histology.
When you look at the macroscopic photograph in Figure 2b, this is a standout ugly duckling lesion as it is larger and darker than the patient’s other moles.

Figure 2b.

Figure 3a.
This is another dysplastic naevus with a raised more darkly pigmented area on the top half than on the bottom. This is highlighted on dermoscopy in Figure 3b, in addition to some other subtle features.

Figure 3b

Figure 4a.
This skin lesion looks like a harmless mole on naked eye examination, however dermoscopic assessment (see Figure 4b) shows subtle features which fit with the histological diagnosis of a dysplastic naevus. This shows the importance of careful assessment with dermoscopy.

Figure 4b. Dermoscopic image of above dysplastic naevus.

Figure 5.
This is a dysplastic naevus which is starting to look a lot more abnormal than a benign mole in terms of its irregular features. The extent of abnormalities is looking more similar to a melanoma.
Melanoma-In-Situ - examples

Figure 6a.
Melanoma in situ with ‘ugly duckling’ sign. Very darkly pigmented and large compared to the patient’s other moles. Figure 1b shows dermoscopic appearance.

Figure 6b.

Figure 7.
On the clinical picture on the top right corner of the image, this melanoma in situ looks irregular with a clear darker area of pigmentation on the mid-left side compared to the rest of the lesion. The main dermoscopic image highlights the irregular features more clearly. You can see two populations of cells, resulting in two dramatically different looking parts of the lesion. Note that the labelled hair follicular openings are normal features also seen in benign moles.
Malignant Melanoma - examples

A melanoma on the lower leg. Note the irregular shape, irregular border, the multiple colours within the lesion, and the abruptly finishing border on the right hand side.



A melanoma on the arm. Note again the irregular shape, border, and varying shades of brown on gross examination. On dermoscopy we can see a pale bluish veil covering the centre of the lesion, and many different colours within the lesion itself.

Within the same lesion, a large network of irregular/non-uniform pigmentation

Witihin the same lesion, large areas of regression/depigmentation

A melanoma on the right cheek.
Gross examination would make you suspicious of melanoma here due to its irregular shape and the 'ugly duckling' sign.
The irregular globules here are white circles which have a subtle brown/grey dot within the follicular opening - this is a sign that melanoma is invading in to the follicles.



A melanoma on the right foot displaying numerous suspicious dermatological features.

A large melanoma on the dorsum of the right foot.



A melanoma hidden at the site of a tattoo.
Note the sharply cut off border on the right hand side of the lesion, and the different colours and shades in the lesion.

A melanoma with a growth at the centre. Note the many different colours within the lesion and the pink structureless area at the top of the lesion.

A simple way to assess pigmented skin lesions: The 3-Point Checklist
Lesions such as the last one pictured have obvious features of melanoma, however from the examples you can see that differentiating between different benign and malignant melanocytic skin lesions can be difficult. Soyer et al. (1) have created a simple 3-point checklist to assess the risk of malignancy in pigmented skin lesions. You can find more information on this here:
https://dermnetnz.org/cme/dermoscopy-course/three-point-checklist
References
1. Soyer HP, Argenziano G, Zalaudek I, Corona R, Sera F, Talamini R, Barbato F, Baroni A, Cicale L, Di Stefani A, Farro P, Rossiello L, Ruocco E, Chimenti S. Three-point checklist of dermoscopy. A new screening method for early detection of melanoma. Dermatology. 2004;208(1):27-31. doi: 10.1159/000075042. PMID: 14730233.